Featured Post

Anxious gatekeeping

Analogous to nervous cluelessness is something we might call “anxious gatekeeping.”   This is desire to police the borders of poetry, or of...

Thursday, January 19, 2017

Life Hack 18: Don't punt--unless you have to...

Suppose you had four strikes to strike out in baseball instead of three?  That would make pitching much more difficulty by reducing the number of strike-outs. Or four outs in an inning rather than 3? That would tip the balance toward offense.  

In football, you have four chances to make another first down. But the last chance is virtually worthless, most of the time, because teams typically kick it away to the other team. So a team that never punted would have four chances instead of three.  That is in increase of 33.33333333%! Put another way, on third down, you would now have two chances, or double the chance, of making a first down.  More than double, in fact, since the third down would get you a bit closer to the first line goal. So teams punt because of football convention, not because it is a good idea, most of the time. It is about minimizing harm rather than maximizing benefit, since, if you don't make it on 4th down, then you are giving the other team better field position.

I can see some places you should punt: when you are deep in your own territory and you would be giving them an automatic score, etc... Or at certain positions in the game clock, or if conditions are just right.  But just punting every single time on fourth down is rather pointless.

I hate sports analogies, but think about this for a minute next time you are in a position to "punt."


Punting can feel like a defeat, but there are other times you have to let go of something and pull back, put less effort into something. Punting in this sense is good thing.


Leslie said...

I don't understand punting and I have looked it up.

What would an example of it be? Buying ready-made food rather than cooking?

Jonathan said...

It's kind of whatever you want to make it.

I don't watch football much, even, but there was a New Yorker article about this difference between the football culture and the statisticians.

Leslie said...

But by punting here do you mean taking the easy short-cut, taking a stop-gap measure when not absolutely necessary, etc.?

Like, doing a shoddy repair when really you should do a good one (and can)?

Or is it passing the buck? "Picking your battles" (i.e. being passive and lazy)?

Jonathan said...

It means that you have to retain control yourself. Punting is giving up control where you have some measure of it.

Leslie said...

OH. *Everyone* I know disagrees with this but me, so I am glad someone else doesn't. I am actually brilliant at not forming unrealistic illusions of control, but it is clear to me one has much more control of much more than people want to believe, and should use it. This is *not* a popular attitude and I have not figured out why, but I think "punting" as you call it is right wing.